BLM Survey Causes Controversy, BSU Reacts

“In your opinion, what does your local community need to do to reduce the escalation of the Black Lives Matter movement?” was the survey question that sparked an uproar of complaints from students on Twitter and on the BSU mobile app feed. 

Part of an Introductory Psychology class-developed research project on “Education in Modern Society,” the question sought to gain a more explicit understanding of racial discrimination and bias. The survey’s hypothetical vignette was originally intended to “elicit predictable responses to better understand how differences in the framing of an issue shape opinions, beliefs, and reactions,” explained President Frederick W. Clark and Provost Ismaili in an email sent to the entire campus community.

The email explained that the survey was part of a larger ongoing investigation into pro and con reactions to issues such as COVID-19 and Black Lives Matter and was approved by BSU’s Institutional Review Board. The university explained the intention was to “elicit predictable responses to better understand how differences in the framing of an issue share opinions, beliefs and reactions” and that the students in the psychology course were provided with substantial information on the survey’s purpose.

Prior to knowing of its intentionally problematic phrasing, the original tweet from BSU student Jenna Higgins expressed confusion towards the survey question saying “@BridgeStateU So you guys just let your psychology students make surveys like this?” and attached a photo of the survey forum. The screenshot also displayed the paragraph that prefaced the question with one sentence deeming the Black Lives Matter movement “a wild beast preying on your local community” and other claims on the movement being dangerous. 

A day later, the same user replied with another tweet including a screenshot that included the student researchers names—Jeremy Hermanson and Noah Wasserman. Other users began replying with comments pertaining to their character with one user stating, “Mf looks like he hates POC.” (POC is a general or “umbrella” term that refers to people of color. Here is an article that explains the difference between the acronyms BIPOC and POC.)

As promised in the first email regarding the survey controversy, the university responded with a list of actions that were completed since the complaints. This task list included conducting small group meetings with students of color to outline areas for immediate action and process the anguish caused by this situation, analyzing policies, creating training modules, and identifying national practices designed to infuse racial justice strategies into university research protocols, and more. 

Sandra Neargarder, a professor and chairperson of psychology at Bridgewater State University, shared her insight, “I think when the students were taking the survey and when they saw the negative version of it, I think they came to the conclusion that this was someone’s political opinion, that the faculty member was stating this rather than it being a part of an actual research study.” Neargarder also stated, according to Enterprise News, that “The intent of the study wasn’t to say anything negative about the Black Lives Matter movement. The university is in full support of Black Lives Matter.”

Essentially, the survey was intentionally worded in a way to collect information on students responses to racist prompts and questions. This caused students to react with outrage by posting on social media to draw attention to what seemed to be a person conducting a survey against the Black Lives Matter movement. Since the tweets provided no research context or survey introduction, students were confused and upset.

The university responded by apologizing, assuming responsibility for its offensive actions, promised to review take action and then followed up a week later with a list of eight ways they began their work to review and resolve the issue.

In my opinion, the purpose of this survey question could be to evoke a reaction that agrees with the question to see if there are any racist biases or discrimination that still lingers in the community. I understand the reactions from the BSU students because someone might question if the ones who constructed the survey feel the same way. 


+ posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Ways to De-Stress on Campus

BSU is hosting some great events on campus to wind down during this stressful time of year that are available for those who just need a break. Finding ways to manage mental health between midterms and finals is crucial to the well-being of all students. Among these events are visits with K9 Mikey, a friendly, […]

How SEAM is Leading a Generation of Strong Educators

As President and Co-President of SEAM (Student Education Association of Massachusetts), Caroline Pupecki (she/her) and Allison Morrissey (she/her) are helping to prepare the next generation of educators. SEAM is part of larger organizations such as the MTA (Massachusetts Teacher’s Association) and its parent organization, the NEA (National Education Association). Through SEAM, students on campus from […]

Want a Career But Can’t Commit? Try an Internship

The question of what to do after graduation can be a daunting one, even for those who are still a few years from graduating. Luckily, students have access to resources that can help get them started on their post-college journey.   The doors of the Career Services and Internships Office, located in Rondileau Student Union […]

An Interview with Miss New Bedford

The reigning Miss New Bedford, Emma Gendreau (she/her), is a BSU sophomore majoring in Severe Disabilities and Political Science.  Gendreau first got involved with pageants at a young age. Not only was she a dancer for the Miss New Bedford choreographer, she also participated in the Little Sister program, “a program for little girls and […]